The Solicitor General clarified the court’s role during a hearing.

New Delhi, September 11, 2025

Clarifying the Supreme Court’s Role

The Solicitor General (SG) emphasized that the Supreme Court is not a headmaster responsible for addressing every issue raised by states. This statement came during a recent hearing where various legal matters were discussed. The SG aimed to clarify the limitations of the court’s jurisdiction regarding state concerns. The role of the Supreme Court should not include micromanaging state governance or issues that can be resolved locally. This perspective reflects the court’s intention to avoid overstepping its boundaries.

The Context of State Concerns

Various states have presented multiple issues to the Supreme Court, seeking specific resolutions. The SG reiterated that while the court plays a vital role in upholding justice, it cannot solve all problems for every state. Some issues are best handled through state legislation and local governance. This assertion underscores the importance of cooperative federalism in India. It also highlights the ongoing challenges faced by states in navigating their legal dilemmas while respecting the court’s purview.

A Call for Local Governance

The SG urged for a more rigorous local governance model, where states take charge of their legal and administrative challenges. The Supreme Court can provide oversight but should not be expected to rectify every local issue. This approach would ensure that states maintain their autonomy while responding effectively to their citizen’s needs. Stakeholders are encouraged to engage more with local governments to foster solutions that do not crowd the judiciary.

As discussions continue, the balance between state autonomy and judicial intervention remains pivotal. This dynamic is crucial for the evolution of India’s legal landscape. Engaging with these challenges requires a deep understanding of both state responsibilities and the judiciary’s role. The SG’s comments serve as a reminder of the importance of delineating powers between different branches of government.

Source: