Housing societies barred from levying extra charges.

Mumbai, September 2, 2025: In a ruling set to impact thousands of cooperative housing societies across Maharashtra, the Bombay High Court has held that societies cannot demand a “welfare fund” or any additional charges from members during the transfer of flat ownership. The court clarified that only fees expressly permitted under the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act and rules can be levied, and imposing welfare charges during membership transfer is illegal.

The judgment came after a dispute where a housing society had demanded a hefty welfare fee from a member who sought to transfer ownership of his flat. The member challenged the demand, arguing that the society was misusing its authority to extract money beyond statutory provisions. The High Court, after hearing arguments, ruled in favour of the member, underscoring that cooperative societies are bound by law and cannot create financial burdens that have no legal basis.

The bench observed that while societies have the right to collect maintenance, repair funds, and statutory charges, the concept of a welfare fee tied to membership transfer does not exist in law. It further stated that such demands amount to an unfair trade practice and violate the cooperative principles on which housing societies are founded. The court emphasized that societies are service-oriented bodies, not profit-making entities, and any attempt to impose arbitrary levies undermines the trust and purpose of the cooperative movement.

Legal experts welcomed the verdict, noting that the practice of charging welfare or donation fees during transfer has been widespread in Mumbai and its suburbs, often leaving buyers and sellers trapped in disputes. Many societies justify such charges as contributions toward community welfare or infrastructure improvements, but the High Court made it clear that unless such collections are explicitly authorized by statute, they are unlawful.

For homebuyers, the ruling offers relief, ensuring smoother transfers without unexpected financial hurdles. It also provides clarity on an issue that has caused long-standing friction between societies and members, with many disputes reaching consumer forums and civil courts. Advocates said the judgment would act as a binding precedent, strengthening members’ rights and discouraging societies from resorting to coercive tactics.

The Maharashtra Cooperative Department is expected to issue a circular soon, reinforcing the High Court’s ruling and instructing societies to strictly comply with the law. Officials hinted that non-compliance could attract penalties, including inquiries against society office bearers who continue to demand illegal fees.

Activists working in the cooperative housing sector said the judgment could lead to greater accountability, especially in Mumbai, where real estate values are high and societies often exploit members with arbitrary charges. They urged the government to set up monitoring mechanisms and complaint redressal cells to ensure residents can report violations easily.

By striking down the practice, the High Court has reaffirmed the principle that cooperative societies exist to serve their members, not exploit them. The verdict is expected to streamline housing transactions and restore fairness in dealings between residents and their managing committees, marking a significant step toward protecting citizens’ housing rights in the state.

Source: